Multi-factor authentication (MFA) asks for a second proof of identity after your password, so a stolen password alone is not enough. Turning on any MFA is one of the most effective steps you can take to protect an account.

But the methods are not equally strong. This guide explains how each one works, how attackers get around it, and which to choose.

The three types of factor

Authentication factors fall into three groups:

  • Something you know — a password or PIN.
  • Something you have — a phone, an authenticator app or a security key.
  • Something you are — a fingerprint or face scan.

MFA combines at least two different types. A password plus a security question is not MFA, because both are things you know.

SMS and voice codes

A one-time code is sent to your phone by text message or call.

  • Strengths: works on any phone, familiar to everyone.
  • Weaknesses: codes can be stolen by SIM swapping (an attacker convinces your mobile provider to move your number to their SIM), and users can be tricked into typing the code into a fake website.

SMS is far better than no MFA, but it is the weakest option. Use it only when nothing else is offered.

Authenticator app codes (TOTP)

Apps such as Microsoft Authenticator, Google Authenticator or the code feature in many password managers generate a new six-digit code every 30 seconds. This is called a time-based one-time password (TOTP).

  • Strengths: no mobile network required, not vulnerable to SIM swapping.
  • Weaknesses: still phishable. A fake login page can ask for your code and pass it to the real site within those 30 seconds.

Push notifications

The service sends an approval request to an app on your phone.

  • Strengths: convenient — one tap.
  • Weaknesses: MFA fatigue attacks, where an attacker who has your password triggers repeated prompts until you approve one just to make them stop.

Number matching — where you type a number shown on the login screen into the app — defeats most fatigue attacks. Microsoft Authenticator uses it by default.

Security keys and passkeys (FIDO2)

Hardware security keys (such as a USB or NFC key) and passkeys stored on your phone, computer or password manager use the FIDO2/WebAuthn standard.

Instead of a code that you type, your device performs a cryptographic check that is tied to the website's real address. A fake site at a different address simply cannot use it. That is why these methods are called phishing-resistant.

  • Strengths: resistant to phishing, fatigue attacks and SIM swapping. Passkeys can also replace the password entirely.
  • Weaknesses: not every service supports them yet. Hardware keys cost money and must not be lost, so register a backup.

Comparison

MethodPhishing-resistantSIM-swap resistantFatigue-attack resistantConvenience
SMS / voice codeNoNoYesMedium
Authenticator app codeNoYesYesMedium
Push notificationNoYesWith number matchingHigh
Security key (FIDO2)YesYesYesHigh
PasskeyYesYesYesVery high

Which should you use?

  1. Passkeys or security keys wherever they are offered — especially for email, Microsoft 365, Google, banking and password managers.
  2. Authenticator app (with number matching for push) everywhere else.
  3. SMS only as a last resort.

Whatever you choose, save your recovery codes somewhere safe, such as your password manager or a printed copy kept securely. Losing your only MFA device without recovery codes can lock you out permanently.